Upper Connecticut River Valley
This ad has been seen 39,873 times
|Naturally Clean : River Valley edition : Thursday, 13 December 2018 01:42 EST : a service of The Public Press|
Read our current paper issue here
Current Issue (PDF)
Who We Are
Who Reads Green Living?
many more articles about
more Health articles
The Snowpants Rule
20 Uses for Coke
The Electric Option
Try Solar Drying
Toxic Pet Toys?
The Dream of Natural Childbirth
If you hate a person, you
hate something in him
that is part of yourself.
What isn't part of
ourselves doesn't disturb
– Hermann Hesse
Naturally Clean: A Book for the Generations
by Stephen Morris
The Precautionary Principle
The authors of Naturally Clean make frequent reference to the "Precautionary Principle," a concept that was first articulated at a conference of scientists and environmentalists in 1998. In the historic Wingspread Statement, they wrote "When an activity raises threats of harm to human health or the environment, precautionary measures should be taken even if some cause and effect relationships are not fully established scientifically."
Critics have called the principle too vague to provide meaningful guidance, but in an article published by the Environmental Research Foundation (August, 2005) author Peter Montague provides a sharper focus: "1) When we have a reasonable suspicion of harm, and 2) scientific uncertainty about cause and effect, then 3) we have a duty to take action to prevent harm.
This ad has been seen 162,394 times
"The precautionary approach suggests five actions we can take: (1) Set a goal (or goals); (2) Examine all reasonable ways of achieving the goal, intending to choose the least-harmful way; (3) Monitor results, heed early warnings, and make mid-course corrections as needed; (4) Shift the burden of proof -- when consequences are uncertain, give the benefit of the doubt to nature, public health and community well-being. Expect responsible parties (not governments or the public) to bear the burden of producing needed information. Expect reasonable assurances of safety for products before they can be marketed -- just as the Food and Drug Administration expects reasonable assurances of safety before new pharmaceutical products can be marketed. (5) Throughout the decision-making process, honor the knowledge of those who will be affected by the decisions, and give them a real 'say' in the outcome."
We apply the Precautionary Principle every time we buckle a seatbelt. Why doesn't it make sense to do the same with the chemicals that surround us?
Editor and Publisher
Naturally Clean is a "company book," meaning that it quietly, but unabashedly, promotes awareness of issues that are addressed by the products it sells. The company, in this case, is Vermont-based Seventh Generation, the nation's leading provider of natural and non-toxic cleaning products and household goods. Proponents of journalistic independence might argue that such a book is inevitably biased by business self-interests, to which this reviewer responds:
"Yeah, but so what?" Companies, especially in Vermont, have learned that it can be a good brand strategy to have a strong and very public sense of values.
There are other strengths to "company" books. Businesses have in-depth product knowledge; businesses have broad experience with consumers; and businesses have resources that run much deeper than the average freelance writer toiling away on a laptop. The team that Seventh Generation President Jeffrey Hollender has assembled for Naturally Clean includes a wordsmith (Geoff Davis), a researcher who specializes in product analysis (Reed Doyle), and a "nice touch", a representative of the next generation, Jeffrey's daughter Meika, a student at New York University.
Companies are also well-connected on both the technical and promotional fronts. Naturally Clean benefits from glowing testimonials from eco-celebrities Nell Newman and Robert Kennedy, Jr. At the other end of the spectrum its content was influenced by, and in some cases scrutinized by, prominent doctors, scientists, and environmentalists.
The result is a credible, attractive volume broken into forty-seven brief chapters with several useful appendices including a resource guide and glossary. There's enough science for the skeptic, but not so much that the reader needs to revisit high school chemistry class.
The "why" of this book is deeply troubling and the authors spend nearly the first one hundred pages why a company like Seventh Generation is necessary. Under the guise of progress we have surrounded ourselves with products that poison us. "Clearly, chemistry itself is not a bad thing," say the authors. "It's the kinds of chemicals we make and use that matter. Like most anything else, there is a good side and a bad side to all the molecular manipulation chemists practice. There are safe chemicals, and there are unsafe chemicals. Our problem today is that we don't really know which are which."
I thought this book might fall into the trap of "don't buy their bad chemicals, buy our good ones," but, refreshingly, many of the recommended cleaning solutions are in the "less is more" category. You will find yourself wanting to go out and buy economy-sized packages of baking soda and vinegar, two inexpensive, non-toxic products that can be used for an infinite number of cleaning challenges. To wit:
Baked-on goo at the bottom of your oven? Been ignoring it since Thanksgiving? Just sprinkle on baking soda and moisten with water. Leave overnight, then wipe off with a wet paper towel the next day. No spray cleaner, no rubber gloves, no fumes, no energy gobbling oven to run, and no threats of divorce!
This book is not for everyone, however. It is not, for instance, for people (like me) who like to keep their heads in the sand about certain unpleasant subjects. When grilling, for example, my approach to sanitation is to scrape the grill with the spatula. No stranger to the cliche "a little dirt never killed anyone" I've been called a guy who keeps the "fun" in "fungus."
Thus, it was difficult for me to read about the myriad of nastiness that could be lurking in my cutting board. It was stressful to learn that up to half of the weight of my pillow could be dust and other mites (half?). I could live easily without knowing the difference between a Perfluorochemical (the basic compound used in non-stick pans)and a Phthlates (an industrial compound used in a variety of products to make them more pliant).
This is not a book for people who want to believe that our governmental institutions are keeping them safe from toxic products. On the contrary, of the 80,000 chemical compounds now in use, only a tiny percentage (one half of one per cent) have ever been tested for carcinogenicity. The rest? We simply do not know.
The operative standard in this country is to base most regulation on a system that says an activity is innocent until proven guilty. While this is effective in keeping Big Brother at bay, it means there are a huge number products in everyday use whose impact on your health is unknown. Seen from this perspective Naturally Clean becomes an important tool to empower individuals to make their own regulatory decisions.
The cheapskate in me loved Naturally Clean for its alternatives to expensive household cleaners. My rebel, pagan, and nostalgic sides were similarly delighted. "Once upon a time, things were different in America's cleaning cupboards. In the days before the chemical revolution of the 20th century, our ancestors relied on naturally occurring materials and substances to help them with the housework. These included things like pure vegetable soaps, grease-cutting vinegars, abrasives like calcium carbonate and baking soda, citrus oils to remove odors and grime, and essential oils of plants like birch and lavender to sanitize surfaces in the home.
DuPont promises "Better Living Through Chemistry." Seventh Generation promises to consider the impact of their deliberations on the seventh generation (adapted from a Native American proverb).
I will take my chances with them.
Excerpt from Naturally Clean
A critical epicenter of activity in our kitchens is the dishwasher. Fifty-one percent of all American homes have one of these time- and labor-saving devices, yet it surprises many to learn that they're the most toxic appliance in the modern home.
Over the course of approximately 30 experiments, researchers at the EPA and the University of Texas recently documented the dishwasher's role as a leading cause of indoor air pollution. Pollutants released by dishwashers include the chlorine added to both public water supplies and dishwasher detergents, volatile organic compounds like chloroform, radioactive radon naturally present in some water sources, and other volatile contaminants that have worked their way into public water supplies. When these materials are exposed to the piping hot water that circulates through your dishwasher as it cleans, they are easily "stripped out" and evaporated into the air.
Depending on the material in question and your water temperature, dishwashers can reach 100 percent efficiency when it comes to transferring water pollutants and detergent chemicals to indoor air. Because these machines vent about six liters of air per minute into your home as they work, they're continuously releasing any water-borne toxins throughout each operating cycle. Even more problematically, the air pollution created by routine venting is often exceeded by the single large burst of contaminated steam that's released whenever a dishwasher is opened before its contents have cooled.
Although it certainly sounds a little odd to say, protecting yourself from your dishwasher means taking steps like these:
advertising : Amelia Shea : 603.924.0056 : RVdesign <at> GreenLivingJournal.com
|site designed by the Caspar Institute|
this site generated with 100% recycled electrons!
send website feedback to the GLJwebster <at> CasparInstitute.org
last updated 20 January 2009 :: 9:04 :m: Yes We Can! Caspar (Pacific) time|
all content and photos copyright © 2001-2017
by Stephen Morris & Michael Potts, Green Living Journal
except as noted
|K 737 2LathropRV1702.jpg||39,873||823||186,581|
|B 727 bnrVTSoapRV134.png||162,394||2,106||181,293|
|M 735 ContraryWheyCH171.jpg||48,248||2,165||188,475|